Ask questions to AI’s trained on the Vedanta teaching material of James Swartz and Swami Paramarthananda. AI is perfect for defining terms, clarifying the meaning of scripture, and refining your understanding.
Much appreciation and gratitude to Andre Vas (YesVedanta.com) for his work setting up and maintaining this invaluable resource.
Here is an actual response to a question posed to the James Swartz AI
The question:
I understand that I am Consciousness, but I don’t see why my experience stays with my individual form and is not distributed across all bodies?
The comprehensive answer:
This is the most crucial and persistent question a Vedanta student faces. You have understood intellectually that you are Consciousness, but you still feel localized because you are confusing the knower with the instrument of knowing.
Let me unfold this precisely for you.
1. The Core Distinction: You Are Not the Experiencer
The first thing to grasp is: experience does not belong to Awareness; it belongs to the body-mind 1.2.
You, Consciousness, are the ultimate knower. You illumine the mind and the senses. But the experience of seeing, hearing, feeling, and thinking happens only when the subtle body (mind, intellect, ego) contacts objects 4.1.
Think of it like electricity. Electricity flows everywhere, but when it functions through a light bulb, it manifests as light. When it passes through a heater, it manifests as heat. Each appliance produces a different “experience,” but the electricity is one 1.11.3.
Your body-mind is one particular “appliance” — an instrument with a unique set of vāsanās (latent tendencies, preferences, conditioning) that limit what appears within its scope 6.4.
________________________________________
2. The Upadhi Effect: The Lens of Ignorance
The tradition calls the body-mind an upādhi — a limiting adjunct. The upādhi makes Awareness appear limited, just as a telescope lens limits the range of your vision. When you look through one telescope, you can’t see what another telescope is seeing, even though the light is the same 6.4.
Here is the exact logic:
• Awareness is one and universal — it “inhabits” or appears as every body-mind-sense complex, enjoying the experiences of every person 6.26.6.
• However, from the limited perspective it assumes when it identifies with a particular body-mind-sense complex, Awareness can only experience the operations taking place within the scope of that apparent individual 6.2.
• To know another person’s experience, you would have to “jump into” their body-mind simultaneously while remaining in your own — which is impossible for an individual confined by boundaries 6.16.2.
So the experience seems locked to your form because the mechanism of experience (the subtle body) is locked to its own boundaries. But the Awareness that illumines that experience is not locked anywhere. It is everywhere, always 2.1.
________________________________________
3. The Analogy of the Movie Projector
The sources offer a beautiful analogy to make this clear:
The process can be likened to the way a projector casts light through a reel of film in a movie theater. When the light shines on the film, images flash on the screen and action appears to take place. Just so, when awareness illumines the body-mind-sense complex, perceptions, emotions, thoughts, and actions seem to occur 6.3.
You are the projector light. Your body-mind is the reel of film. The film is distinctly patterned — it has its own story, its own characters, its own vāsanās. The light takes on the coloration of that particular film.
But the light itself is not contaminated by the film, and it does not move from one projector to another. It simply illumines whatever film is in front of it. If you identify with the light, you are free. If you identify with the film, you feel trapped in the story.
You are not the story happening in another projector because you, as the apparent individual, are just the reflection of Awareness on a particular medium. But you, as pure Awareness, are the light that shines through all projectors simultaneously — even if you don’t know it yet because you are hypnotized by the film 6.3.
________________________________________
4. Why Don’t You Experience Everyone Else’s Thoughts?
This is a natural question that follows. If you are the one Awareness, why don’t you have everyone’s memories, feelings, and knowledge?
The answer is: Because the vāsanas are local, even though Awareness is not 6.6.
• Your body-mind is a specific aggregate of gross and subtle matter, conditioned by its unique history of choices 1.1.
• When Awareness shines through that aggregate, it appears as the specific person you think you are, with all your skills, aptitudes, likes, and dislikes 6.4.
• The vrittis (thoughts) that arise in your mind are formed only when your senses contact objects within their field. You cannot form a thought about another person’s mind because your senses cannot contact it 4.2.
But here is the ultimate twist: the awareness that knows your thoughts is the very same awareness that knows the thoughts of everyone else. It is one, singular, and non-dual 6.56.6. You are just looking at it from a very narrow point of view — the point of view of the upādhi.
________________________________________
5. The Final Truth: You Already Experience Everything
Now, let’s dissolve the confusion completely. If you say you are Consciousness, then you are not the experiencer 4.3. Experience is a movement in the mind, but you, Awareness, are the actionless, unchanging witness in which all experiences appear and disappear 7.1.
And because this is true, you are already experiencing everything — not as an individual who receives information through senses, but as the Consciousness in which the entire universe rises and falls. As the texts say:
“The same Awareness looks out through the sense organs of every conscious entity.” 5.1
“The Awareness that animates others is the same Awareness that animates you.” 1.1
Your problem is that you keep looking for the “distributed experience” inside your local body-mind. You want your personal brain to know things. But that is like asking the light bulb to feel the heat of the heater. The bulb feels only light; the heater feels only heat. Yet the single electricity is present in both 1.3.
You, as Consciousness, are perfectly aware of the experience of every body-mind-sense complex in the entire universe. But this knowledge is only available when you stop identifying with the local instrument and stand as the formless, all-pervading Awareness that you are 2.2.
________________________________________
6. A Concrete Contemplation for You
To move this from intellectual understanding to direct knowledge, contemplate this:
1. In deep sleep, where is your individual body? It is gone. Where is your individual mind? It is gone. Yet you exist — as blissful, complete Awareness 1.43.1.
2. In that state, the “distribution” of experience across bodies is irrelevant, because there are no separate bodies. There is only you, experiencing yourself.
3. When you wake up, the limiting adjuncts (upādhis) reappear, and you forget your true nature, reasserting the illusion of locality.
4. Knowledge is seeing that the locality was never real. It is apparent — like the snake on the rope. Remove the ignorance, and the “problem” of distribution disappears along with the separate individual 4.17.2.
________________________________________
Summary: Why Experience Stays With Your Form
• Experience is produced by a body-mind-sense complex contacting objects (a local mechanism) 4.1.
• Consciousness is the non-local light that illumines this contact 4.2.
• You are that Consciousness, not the local mechanism 5.1.
• You feel localized because you are identified with the subtle body, which has specific vāsanās and boundaries 6.4.
• When this identification is removed through self-knowledge, you see that all experiences are yours, because you are all-pervasive Consciousness 6.5.
Original from Shining World Newsletter
https://shiningworld.substack.com/p/summer-seminar-updates?utm_source=email&redirect=app-store-no-desktop&inbox=true&utm_campaign=email-read-in-app&triedRedirect=true
